Taking IT to the streets: 3G arrives

Taking IT to the streets: 3G arrives

Call it the end of downtime -- all those offline hours wasted in useless conference sessions or at the airport -- and the start of rich applications accessible virtually anywhere. Whether your preferred device is a handheld or a notebook, in a year or so 3G networks will effectively reinvent how your mobile enterprise conducts business.

Say, for example, you're at a client site and suddenly discover that you need more details on a consulting project. No problem. You'll turn on your device and connect to the corporate servers that run your enterprise apps. You'll be able to check e-mail and to participate in workgroup projects as if you were at your office. Colleagues may not even know you're off-site because you'll be doing your normal work in the normal way.

That has been the big promise of 3G cellular networks -- one that has gone unrealised for half a decade, as cellular carriers postponed deployments and instead rolled out low-speed (30Kbps to 70Kbps) 2.5G networks, which even dial-up modem connections can outrun. "You can't run rich applications" on 2.5G networks, concedes Kenny Wyatt, assistant vice president of integrated solutions at Sprint PCS.

But this year, carriers are finally starting to make good on their word. The first parts of real 3G networks are already here, offering throughputs between 200Kbps and 400Kbps -- equivalent to the early DSL networks that revolutionised the home office. Verizon Wireless has deployed the CDMA2000 1xEvDO (evolution, data optimised) technology in no fewer than 15 urban areas in the US and plans to make the service available nationwide by 2007. Sprint PCS promises to start offering its own EvDO service later this year in a handful of cities before expanding nationally. Cingular Wireless now offers in six cities the UMTS (Universal Mobile Telecommunications System) service it inherited from AT&T Wireless and plans to roll out a faster HSDPA (High-Speed Downlink Packet Access) service later this year. T-Mobile USA plans to start deploying HSDPA in 2006.

After carriers have completed their rollouts, 3G should be available broadly enough -- and with enough user capacity -- for enterpises to rely on it. Between now and then, however, businesses will have to decide whether the available coverage and capacity will be sufficient for their needs. Given the wireless industry's history of overstated claims for earlier-generation data services and its tendency to focus on consumer applications such as downloadable ring tones and camera phones, the question remains whether the carriers will truly follow through on their 3G promises, says Phil Smith, vice president of global solution marketing at IT consultancy Unisys.

EvDO is the 3G technology for CDMA-based networks, such as those used by Verizon Communications and Sprint. UMTS and HSDPA are the 3G technology for GSM-based networks, used by Cingular and T-Mobile. All-you-can-eat service costs approximately $US80 per month and typically includes access to 2.5G networks -- CDMA2000 1xRTT (Radio Transmission Technology) for CDMA users and GPRS and EDGE (Enhanced Data GSM Environment) for GSM users -- to ensure connectivity when users move outside 3G coverage areas.

Although 3G has the potential to revolutionise notebook users' productivity on the road, its benefit for handheld users is less clear, at least in the near term.

Notebook users: take your office with you Sandy Potter -- vice president of business development at Canvas Systems, a provider of refurbished computer equipment -- has experience using 2.5G networks and has found them significantly lacking. They were so slow, she recalls, that she brought her computer into the IT staff because she thought it was failing. Her timing was good: IT was testing an EvDO service and gave her a card. The difference in performance was dramatic.

"It's as though I'm sitting at my desk. It allows me to be out of the office for five or six days and not be backlogged when I come back," Potter says. "It's all about how you can do more deals in the same time -- and not have a backlog that takes a weekend to go through or interrupts the group's workflow." Another advantage is that, when visiting clients, Potter and her staff don't have to use the client's network to get broadband access.

"3G provides the potential for enterprise services to run over the wide area network," says Mark Morell, director of strategic marketing for carrier networks at Nortel Networks, which provides the carriers equipment for their 3G systems. "We expect to see mobile users have the same services and capabilities as in their offices."

When fully deployed, "3G will reduce the expectation gap and the delivery gap between wireless and wired connections," says Antoine Blondeau, vice president of wireless at "The user experience will compare to the Web experience." And Blondeau speaks from personal experience: "I've had an EvDO card for a while, and it works nicely. I'm using my laptop more often, and I'm doing more complex tasks (over the air) with it."

Oracle, for example, expects the arrival of 3G to change how its customers use Oracle software on the road, says Jacob Christfort, vice president of server technology at the database provider. "In the 2.5G world, we did not see much use of our eBusiness Suite (by mobile users). 3G will make these Oracle applications available to them," he says. It also should ease the workload for the IT group: With 3G connections, "IT just manages a Web-based application and no longer needs to worry about synchronising databases since there's no longer a need for a parallel system for mobile users," he says.

For IT, providing 3G access to notebook users is simple: subscribe to the service and hand out 3G modem cards to users. Novatel Wireless currently offers EvDO and UMTS modem cards and plans to support HSDPA soon. Sierra Wireless also provides EvDO cards and plans to release UMTS/HSDPA cards in the future. Current 3G modems aren't backward-compatible with 2.5G networks such as 1xRTT and GPRS, so users would need both modems if they frequently travel in non-3G areas.

When they lose 3G service, they'll need to swap their 3G modem card with a 2.5G modem card and then connect to the 2.5G network. When they re-enter 3G terrain, they'll need to revert to the 3G card. Fortunately, new models planned for later this year will support both 3G and 2.5G networks, thereby eliminating the need to carry two modem cards.

Users access the corporate services through the same remote-access protocols that any other remote employees would use. "You log in to the network just as if you were using a DSL or cable modem," Nortel's Morell says. That could mean the use of VPNs, Web-based access, or terminal emulation such as Citrix servers -- the enterprise uses the same remote-access mechanism provided to users from a home broadband connection, an Internet terminal, or a Wi-Fi hot spot.

In an effort to secure their 3G networks, carriers have tapped technology built into the CDMA and GSM protocols to encrypt over-the-air data and hinder access by snoopers. Customers, however, remain responsible for securing connections from carrier networks through the public Internet and into their enterprise systems and must secure user devices themselves. That means 3G users will have the same security methods -- encryption, VPNs, hardware IDs, password challenges and so forth -- as any other remote user supported by their enterprise.

This standard remote-access security could be less than enterprises are used to with messaging services such as those from Research In Motion (RIM) and Good Technology. That's because the messaging services typically provide a high level of encryption and initiate the connection to the device, so the enterprise retains full control over the communications. As is any other remote device, a 3G-connected device is capable of initiating connections itself. And the encryption level implemented by IT may be less than what RIM or Good Technology offer.

The increased reliance on mobile devices encouraged by 3G networks means that IT should consider developing a mobile security policy that includes protecting the device's contents as well as its access to enterprise servers, says Marvin Chartoff, CTO of global infrastructure services at Unisys. Enterprises will also demand the ability to "kill" a lost or stolen device so that its data can no longer be accessed, he adds.

Although disabling a device remotely is possible over 2.5G networks, a faster, more reliable 3G connection "means the minute that I know the device is lost, I can zap it", says Ojas Rege, senior director of mobile solutions at Sybase mobile subsidiary iAnywhere Solutions. The faster speeds of 3G increases the chances of the "kill" command being received by the device before the thief prevents that action.

Wi-Fi networks, by contrast, often use inferior security mechanisms, and in many cases not even the basic security has been turned on. Wi-Fi networkscan be deployed by almost anyone, so the level of security know-how often varies widely.

Incremental gains for handheld users The arrival of 3G will have a less dramatic effect on handheld users because these devices and their applications were designed mainly for offline uses, with occasional synchronisation via a cradle or slow cellular connection necessary when the user moves from one location to another.

Good Technology, which provides a messaging service used largely by executives on handheld devices, expects 3G to help bring richer applications to handheld devices. "EvDO and HSDPA will help make GoodAccess take off," says John Friend, CTO of Good Technology.

GoodAccess allows IT to build and deploy applications that connect to back-office products such as SFA and ERP, but the slow 2.5G networks have kept adoption low, Friend notes. (Executives at RIM, makers of the BlackBerry messaging device and service, declined to comment on how the company might take advantage of 3G connections, although in Europe it has used the technology to provide application access similar to GoodAccess.)'s Blondeau expects both IT and third-party software developers to start taking high-speed access into consideration as they create mobile applications. That would mean less reliance on storing local data, for example. "The need for a fully asynchronous architecture is reduced," he says.

Blondeau also expects Web services to increasingly support access from handhelds, by using technologies such as DHTML and XML to present an appropriate interface for the handheld's smaller screen and limited input capability -- reducing the need for separate mobile applications.

Given that 3G networks will also allow over-the-air management of mobile device, enterprises will be able to upload application and antivirus updates -- files too large to transmit across 2.5G networks. Both Good Technology and RIM already offer management services for their devices. Both devices are part of an overall service that includes a messaging server at the enterprise, so it makes sense for the enterprise to manage that service directly.

For carrier-supplied 3G services,'s Blondeau says it's natural for the carriers to provide such services, rather than having IT deploy it, because carriers will be rolling out multiple applications over multiple devices and thus must figure out the connectivity and management capabilities anyway.

Anticipating this demand, Sprint PCS will offer its Managed Mobility Services later this year. In addition to updating software and disabling missing devices, the service will allow IT to provision services to new users, including specifying their capabilities and access rights. Cingular Wireless is contemplating a similar service.

If the carrier provides the management infrastructure, the enterprise still must manage the devices and services using a Web application. But enterprises that prefer not to outsource their management activities don't have to: A few companies -- including iAnywhere's XcelleNet division and Intellisync (formerly named Pumatech) -- provide their own device management platforms that work via Wi-Fi and cellular networks.

The 3G handheld may provide an additional benefit, notes Good Technology's Friend: With a Bluetooth or UWB (Ultra Wideband) wireless connection, a 3G handheld can act as a modem for a laptop, so a user could share one 3G service plan between the two devices. That would mark a real revolution: a mobile phone giving the notebook real broadband speed.

Even if you end up with a separate 3G card for your notebooks, that broadband speed will untether business travelers and field forces from hotels, hot spots, and other location-specific connections. Assuming the 3G networks are rolled out broadly and with sufficient capacity, that will keep you connected and as productive as any desktop employee -- that is until you run out of battery power.

[sidebar] Wireless operators hate business By Tom Yager

Wireless operators love consumers. Consumers are bottomless wells of continuing revenue, boosting the operator's ARPU (average revenue per user) from text-messaging fees, ring-tone and game downloads, and now music and video. Businesses, on the other hand, are a pain.

Except for giant enterprises, a business delivers lousy ARPU. Businesses want detailed paper billing grouped by division or department. They're slow to pay because that's just the way business is done. They want premium services, such as e-mail, which are tough for operators to maintain. They expect add/change orders to be processed immediately. They want choice in devices, the freedom to switch operators, responsive human support, and the ability to deal face-to-face instead of through consumer channels. They make more use of long distance and roaming, services that operators must bundle in order to keep competitive.

Huge enterprise sales make the extra cost and effort worthwhile, but if a business isn't buying hundreds of phones, device manufacturers defer to operators instead of dealing direct, and operators won't budge from their published rates.

Operators are developing ways to maximise ARPU on non-enterprise business accounts. They're reworking service plans to make all voice minutes, not just daytime minutes, more expensive in plans that focus on daytime access. As opposed to consumer plans, which are loaded with giveaway minutes, business plans are prepaid metered services with the first batch of minutes sold at a moderate discount.

Operators are also boosting business account ARPU by restricting access to data services. Some operators used to compete on data service, even offering unlimited service for a fixed fee, but as are business-grade voice plans, data plans that offer more than a consumer phone's limited browser are either expensive or metered.

Because the revenue brought in by business wireless customers is minuscule compared with consumer revenue, operators have no incentive to compete for business customers on rates, devices, or services. No competition means there's no pressure to upgrade infrastructure for services such as high-speed data, which consumers seldom use, and there's no downward pressure on prices.

Yet operators are finding ways to wring more ARPU out of businesses. Higher-end devices such as BlackBerry, Pocket PC, Symbian Series 60 (especially Nokia), and Treo phones and handhelds are catching on among a new class of subscribers called mobile professionals. These mobile-pro devices are much more profitable than throwaway phones.

What's more, third-party vendors such as Nokia, Research In Motion and Seven Networks are shifting the technical burden of managing business services -- including device management, e-mail, security and Internet access -- onto subscribers, leaving operators with a lot less work to do for business customers. They'll be overjoyed when a business account requires no more setup and hand-holding than a consumer account does.

That day will come. Some operator will eventually break from the pack and go after mobile professionals and businesses with attractive service plans that make daytime minutes and data access cheaper than the present market standards.

Until then, the best strategy for customers is to make it easy to switch. Purchase devices at full price instead of going for a contract. Even though it costs a little more, paying month-to-month gives you the freedom to switch service plans or operators at will. If all business customers did that, it would force competition among operators, who will do anything to convert month-to-month customers to contracts.

Furthermore, ask that mobile-pro devices be delivered to you unlocked -- capable of moving from one operator to another -- but be aware that even an unlocked phone won't work on an incompatible network. For example, a GSM BlackBerry from T-Mobile can't be made to work on Verizon Communications' CDMA network.

And finally, if you can afford it, set up a behind-the-firewall mobile server that handles messaging, synchronisation, tracking, management and Internet access so that you won't be dependent on an operator for these services. If you follow this strategy, when competition finally comes to the mobile market, you'll be ready to go where the value, speed, and coverage are best.

Join the CIO New Zealand group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.

Join the newsletter!


Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

More about ACTAT&TAT&T WirelessBlackBerryCingular WirelessCitrix Systems Asia PacificiAnywhereiAnywhere SolutionsNokiaNortelNortel NetworksNovatelNovatel WirelessOraclePromiseProvisionPumatechResearch In MotionSalesforce.comSierraSierra WirelessSpeedSprintSprint PCSSybase AustraliaSymbianT-MobileUMTSUnisys AustraliaVerizonVerizon WirelessVIAXcelleNet

Show Comments